As a second wave of COVID-19 spreads across Canada and much of the world, it’s natural for some parents to question whether or not it is safe to send their children to school. Even with parts of Ontario in “lockdown”, schools are still open, leaving some to question whether it’s responsible to do so. We can expect an increase in court decisions related to this second wave. A recent decision from British Columbia shows how the courts continue to approach this issue.
The father applied to the court seeking an order requiring the parties’ two children to attend in-person schooling. The application was opposed by the mother, who wanted to homeschool the children during the pandemic. Their children are eight-years-old and four-years-old respectively. If homeschooling for the year was not to be an option, the mother asked that she be able to homeschool for at least a “transition” period.
The court noted that there is little authority out of British Columbia in relation to requiring in-person schooling during the pandemic. The court stated that while British Columbia and Ontario may have different operating guidelines for schools, the decision from Zinati v Spence in Ontario is of “particular assistance.” The decision states that it is not the role of the courts to determine whether large government-run schools are safe to send children to. The courts do not have experts available to second-guess the decision making of the government. While there is no guaranteed safety for any child, a number of factors can be used to determine what is in the best interests of the child, including:
When schools first closed in the spring, the mother homeschooled the children while she had primary parenting responsibilities. The father works outside of the home and would not be able to assist with homeschooling.
At the time the issue was heard, the children had not yet returned to school due to the mother’s opposition to doing so. The court found it was in the children’s best interests to return to in-person schooling, particularly for them to maintain connections with others in order to foster their developmental well-being. While there is some risk that the children could come in contact with someone who has COVID-19 and pass it along to others, there is no guaranteed safety from the virus anywhere, and a general risk such as that is not enough to keep the children at home.
The court ordered the children to return to school at the earliest possible moment.
Separation, divorce, and other family disputes are generally stressful and emotional. If you are contemplating a separation or divorce, your best short term plan is to contact an experienced family lawyer immediately to understand your options, and to formulate a strategy for moving forward. Contact the knowledgeable, effective, and compassionate family lawyer at NULaw online or at 416-481-5604 to book a consultation.
Tel: +1 416 481 5604 Fax: +1 416 481 5829
NULaw proudly services clients in Toronto and throughout Ontario