Ontario law provides that when an individual has designated a beneficiary for life insurance proceeds, those proceeds will not be counted as assets of the deceased’s estate. Instead, the proceeds will be treated according to the designation, unless the estate is named as the beneficiary, in which case the funds may be subject to any creditor claims against the estate. Ontario courts have emphasized that insurance proceeds will normally flow to the chosen beneficiary, and that designations are given significant weight and are not easily challenged.
Giesbrecht v. Strecker concerned the interpretation of the deceased’s will and the treatment of life insurance proceeds. The deceased had obtained a life insurance policy that named her estate as the beneficiary. Her will made several specific bequests, including a clause directing that “all personal property personally of which I may die possessed” was to be conveyed to her daughter Natalie. There was also a clause directing how the residue of her estate should be treated. The estate trustee argued that the life insurance proceeds formed part of the estate’s residue. However, Natalie’s position was that they were personal property and formed part of the specific bequest.
In Moore v. Sweet, the Supreme Court of Canada explained that the Insurance Act provides a comprehensive scheme governing the rights of parties to a life insurance policy, and noted that a beneficiary designation identifies the recipient of the proceeds upon the death of the insured person. In Giesbrecht, the judge noted that beneficiary designations in the life insurance policies have been normally found to be “unassailable”. In this case, the estate was listed as the intended beneficiary of the life insurance policy. For the judge, if the deceased had wanted Natalie to be the beneficiary, she could simply have designated her as the beneficiary on the policy, but chose not to do so. Alternatively, the deceased could have made a specific bequest in her will directing that the insurance proceeds be gifted to Natalie. But this was not done either, even though the deceased made several other specific bequests in her will.
The judge noted that, unlike other cases concerning life insurance proceeds upon the insured’s death, this was not an instance in which a trust was asserted over the proceeds, nor was there any evidence of a contractual entitlement to the insurance proceeds. Instead, Natalie was merely claiming that the proceeds were personal property and should be included in the specific bequest. Natalie pointed out that the estate trustee completed an estate administration form and listed the insurance proceeds as personal property. However, the judge noted that the prescribed form contains only two categories: real property and personal property. And since the policy named the estate as the beneficiary, the estate trustee had to include the proceeds under “personal property” as there was no other place to list it. But the judge did not believe that listing the proceeds in this manner was an acknowledgement by the estate trustee that the proceeds constituted personal property within the meaning of the will and formed part of the specific bequest to Natalie.
The estate trustee also pointed to the specific wording in the will which was used by the deceased. The Trustee argued that the deceased did not own the proceeds when she died, and instead the estate only became entitled to them after she died. Therefore, it did not make any sense to suggest the proceeds could constitute personal property. The judge determined there was no ambiguity in the will, and that the deceased had clear intentions on the distribution of her estate. She made specific bequests of her property and named the individuals who were to benefit. She also provided that the residue of her estate was to be distributed in a specific manner. Here, the deceased clearly obtained a life insurance policy naming her estate as the beneficiary. There was nothing in the will that revoked or amounted to a declaration that the proceeds formed a specific bequest to Natalie.
In the Estate of Christina Georgiou Psoma involved a contentious estate dispute, in which the parties disputed whether the deceased’s life insurance proceeds were intended to benefit the estate. The deceased obtained a life insurance policy and designated a nephew, Steve, as the sole beneficiary. The respondents objected to the estate administration and claimed that Steve, as the estate trustee, had an obligation to apply those proceeds to the deceased’s funeral and burial costs, thereby reducing the debts owed by the estate. They claimed that was what the deceased had intended when she obtained the insurance. In contrast, Steve argued he was entitled to the proceeds, but despite that entitlement and the other debts owed to him by the deceased’s estate, he gifted the proceeds to certain individuals in accordance with verbal instructions the deceased had given him.
The judge began by referring to the provisions of the Insurance Act. In particular, section 190(1) enables an individual to designate a beneficiary for whose benefit insurance proceeds are paid. Section 196(1) clarifies that when a beneficiary is designated, the insurance proceeds do not form part of the estate of the insured, and are not subject to any claims by creditors of the insured. For the judge, those provisions, coupled with the designation of Steve as the beneficiary, appeared to provide a conclusive answer to the suggestion that Steve was not entitled to retain the proceeds free of any obligation to treat the funds as estate assets or to use them to satisfy the estate’s creditors.
Nevertheless, the judge acknowledged that different arrangements could arise, and that courts can ensure compliance with an arrangement where a deceased designates a beneficiary on a life insurance policy, and communicates to the intended beneficiary that they are being designated the beneficiary provided they agree to hold the proceeds in trust on the specified terms, and the beneficiary accepts the obligation. The judge believed this arrangement could be enforced by a constructive trust “to prevent the use of legislation as an instrument of fraud, and thereby prevent unjust enrichment”. This prevents the Insurance Act from being used by an individual to claim the benefit of insurance proceeds free of any obligation, in circumstances where they are made a beneficiary to deal with the proceeds as specified by the deceased.
In this instance, the judge did not believe such an obligation existed, and did not accept the suggestion that, before the testator’s death, Steve was made aware of a wish for the proceeds to be put towards her funeral expenses. The judge found the argument was unsupported. Alternatively, Steve’s explanations were credible, in part, because they were made against his own interests, by undermining any suggestion he was entitled to receive the proceeds free of any obligation. Consequently, the judge held that the assertion that the proceeds were held in trust for the benefit of the deceased’s estate failed.
Disputes over life insurance proceeds can leave Ontario estate trustees and beneficiaries unsure who is entitled to the payout or whether it can be used to cover funeral expenses and other estate debts. NULaw helps clients resolve disputes involving life insurance beneficiary designations, will interpretation, and estate administration.
If you are administering an estate or facing a dispute over who should receive a life insurance payout, contact us online or call 416-481-5604 to schedule a consultation and discuss your options.
Tel: +1 416 481 5604 Fax: +1 416 481 5829
NULaw proudly services clients in Toronto and throughout Ontario
© 2026 NULaw. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy and Disclaimer. Website designed and managed by Umbrella Legal Marketing